Update
menu icon
search icon
×

43 Stories Where the Bad Guy Was Right

Published: by · This post may contain affiliate links ·

Often, the line between hero and villain blurs, revealing layers of complexity and unforeseen perspectives. In this article, we will unravel tales where the supposed antagonists, whether in classic literature, cinema, or real-life scenarios, emerge as characters deserving a second look.

A man watching a horror movie on a TV.

Prepare to challenge preconceptions, question the traditional notions of right and wrong, and discover the unexpected justifications that lend credence to the so-called "bad guys."

Jump to:

1. Donald Duck

Donald Duck toy

Donald Duck, the iconic Disney character, is often portrayed as the short-tempered "bad guy" in many cartoons. However, delve a bit deeper, and you will find that Donald is just a duck trying to enjoy some peace and quiet. In every single cartoon, he is minding his own business when someone, usually his nephews or other characters, disrupts his tranquility.

As we grow older, it becomes evident that Donald is simply standing up for his right to relaxation and personal space. He is just an ordinary duck caught in a series of unfortunate events that make us question who the real troublemakers are.

2. Pierce Brosnan's Character in Mrs. Doubtfire

In the classic film Mrs. Doubtfire, Pierce Brosnan's character emerges as a sympathetic figure amidst the chaos of the plot. A lonely middle-aged man longing for a sense of family, he embodies genuine kindness and sincerity. Despite his best efforts, he becomes involved in the absurd antics directed by Robin Williams' Mrs. Doubtfire.

Mrs. Doubtfire, in her pursuit of protecting the family and perhaps fueled by misplaced jealousy, treats Brosnan's character with unwarranted disdain. The narrative invites viewers to empathize with Brosnan's character, who, despite facing unexpected challenges, continues to embody kindness and genuine affection.

3. Ken in Bee Movie

Ken in Bee Movie is often perceived as a "bad guy" in a somewhat comedic and exaggerated way, primarily for the sake of humor in the storyline. The movie plays on the trope of a boyfriend who is oblivious or somewhat dismissive of the protagonist's evolving relationship with another character.

In reality, Ken is not truly a villain; he is just a regular guy who finds himself in a peculiar situation. His character is designed to add humor and complications to the plot, particularly as Barry, the bee, becomes an unexpected competitor for Vanessa's attention. Ken's role in the story is more about exploring the absurdity of the situation rather than casting him as a genuine antagonist.

4. The Giant in the Jack and the Beanstalk

The classic fairy tale of Jack and the Beanstalk often casts Jack as the hero and the giant as the villain. However, consider the story from the giant's perspective: a stranger barges into his home and starts looting his belongings, taking the best treasures without a second thought. Suddenly, the giant becomes a victim of theft and invasion.

Jack, who comes off as the daring protagonist, might be seen as the antagonist from the giant's point of view. This perspective shift challenges the traditional narrative and invites audiences to question whether Jack's actions are truly heroic or if he is just a trespassing troublemaker with a knack for thievery.

5. Tom the Cat

Tom and Jerry toys.

In the classic cat-and-mouse dynamic of Tom and Jerry, Tom is often labeled as the antagonist. However, take a moment to view the situation from Tom's perspective. His role as the house cat is to maintain order and keep the household free of pests. Enter Jerry, a mischievous mouse who frequently steals food and wreaks havoc.

Tom, just doing his feline duty, becomes the victim of the chaos initiated by Jerry. Suddenly, the tables turn, and Tom's seemingly aggressive actions are merely a cat trying to fulfill his natural instincts. This reframing challenges the conventional narrative, inviting viewers to reconsider who the real troublemaker is in this timeless cartoon rivalry.

6. The Pirates in Peter Pan

The enchanting tale of Peter Pan takes a darker turn when you consider the plight of the so-called "bad guys" — the pirates. Unveiling a different perspective, these pirates are portrayed as grown-up lost boys whom Peter brought to Neverland.

Far from being malicious, they find themselves trapped in a perpetual state of adolescence, yearning to leave the fantastical world and return to their normal lives. Captain Hook and his crew are actually victims of Peter's whimsical and selfish escapades.

7. Squidward from SpongeBob SquarePants

While not necessarily a "bad guy," Squidward becomes a relatable character for adults in the whimsical world of SpongeBob SquarePants. As an adult, you can't help but feel sorry for Squidward because SpongeBob's unrelenting enthusiasm and naivety are constantly bombarding him.

Squidward's desire for peace and quiet is understandable, and his frustration resonates with those who have experienced the challenges of dealing with overly enthusiastic individuals in real life.

8. The Woman in McDonald's Coffee Lawsuit

While widely mocked, the woman who sued McDonald's for serving excessively hot coffee had a legitimate grievance. The fast-food giant ignored repeated warnings to lower the temperature of their coffee, leading to severe burns for the elderly plaintiff. Rather than being the punchline of a joke, she becomes a victim of corporate negligence.

This story challenges our preconceived notions and prompts us to question who the real "bad guy" is—the woman seeking medical bill coverage or the corporation responsible for causing her traumatic injuries.

9. Katherine Heigl's Character in Knocked Up

In the comedy film Knocked Up, perceptions of the characters evolve with age. Initially seen as a frigid character needing to lighten up, Katherine Heigl's role takes on a different light as we age.

In our 30s, we realize that Seth Rogen's character, while entertaining, does not have his life together. The stress and responsibility of impending parenthood understandably weigh on Heigl's character. What once seemed like an uptight attitude now becomes a valid concern for the future of their family. This shift in perspective makes Heigl's character relatable for adults who understand the complexities of adulthood and parenthood.

10. The Story of Medusa

A statue of Perseus holding Medusa's head.

In the myth of Medusa, she is often depicted as the villain turned monster, but a closer look reveals a tragic tale of victimhood. Minding her own business, Medusa finds herself repeatedly targeted by men attempting to kill her. The original story takes a darker turn, revealing that she was cursed by Athena after being raped by Poseidon.

Suddenly, Medusa transforms from a monstrous figure to a victim of divine injustice. Her transformation becomes a metaphor for the consequences of society blaming survivors rather than addressing the actions of the perpetrators.

11. Iceman in Top Gun

In the high-flying world of Top Gun, Iceman emerges as an unexpected voice of reason. Working in naval aviation sheds light on the fact that Iceman's concerns about Maverick are not unfounded. Maverick's dangerous and unreliable behavior poses a real threat to safety protocols. Iceman's only desire is for Maverick to respect these protocols instead of constantly pushing the limits.

Far from being the antagonist, Iceman becomes the advocate for responsible and safe practices in a world where bravado often takes center stage. This perspective shift challenges the perception of Iceman as the "bad guy" and prompts us to appreciate his commitment to safety.

12. Red Forman in That '70s Show

In the nostalgic sitcom That '70s Show, Red Foreman's gruff parenting style is often portrayed humorously, but a deeper analysis reveals he might have been onto something. Red consistently argues that Eric and his friends are a bunch of dumbasses in need of discipline. As we reflect on our own teenage years, Red's frustration with the antics of the gang becomes relatable.

His desire to instill discipline and responsibility in a group of teenagers who often lack foresight challenges the perception of Red as just a curmudgeonly father. In the end, he may have been right about the boot in the ass being a necessary wake-up call for Eric and his friends.

13. General Hummel on The Rock

In the action-packed film The Rock, the character of General Francis Hummel takes on a different light when you consider his motives. Beyond the surface, the general's ultimate goal is to ensure benefits are paid to the families of fallen soldiers. He feels a sense of responsibility and justice for those who gave their lives despite his actions appearing to be villainous.

The persona of General Hummel serves as a poignant reminder that sometimes the "bad guy" has compassion and a desire for justice.

14. Shylock from The Merchant of Venice

Shylock in The Merchant of Venice is often cast as the villain, but a closer look reveals a more nuanced character. His insistence on the pound of flesh as collateral can be seen as a desperate attempt to seek retribution for the mistreatment he endured as a Jew.

Shylock's actions are shaped by the societal discrimination he faces, and his famous speech "Hath not a Jew eyes?" humanizes him. The play makes us ponder whether Shylock is truly a villain or a victim of the prejudices embedded in the society of the time.

15. Card Counters in the Casino

Poker game in a casino.

Card counters, often portrayed as villains, are, in reality, individuals utilizing a skill that casinos find threatening. Many casino documentaries tend to emphasize the casino's viewpoint, painting card counters as rule-breakers when, in truth, they are not engaging in any illicit activities.

Card counting, far from cheating, is a skill that involves keen observation and memorization. It is akin to being banned from chess tournaments for "using your head too much," a concept that challenges the idea of punishing individuals for excelling at a particular game.

16. Mr. McGregor from Peter Rabbit

In the classic tale of Peter Rabbit, the titular character is often seen as a mischievous troublemaker. However, shifting the perspective to Mr. McGregor reveals a different narrative. Peter Rabbit, depicted as a thief, glutton, and trespasser, becomes a symbol of naughtiness. On the other hand, Mr. McGregor is a hardworking individual seeking to produce something of value and feed his family.

Suddenly, Peter's actions, while entertaining, are seen as disruptive and potentially harmful to the farmer's livelihood. The story makes us question whether Peter's antics are just harmless fun or if there's a cost to his mischievous behavior that impacts those around him.

17. Fenrir from Norse Mythology

Delving into Norse mythology, the tragic tale of Fenrir unfolds as a story of betrayal and imprisonment. Taken from his home and feared by everyone without cause, Fenrir becomes a victim of circumstances. Chained and subjected to a sword preventing him from closing his mouth, he faces mockery and imprisonment for many years.

In actuality, anyone subjected to such extreme circumstances would understandably experience a descent into madness. Fenrir's story invites us to question the fairness of his treatment and the consequences of his tragic fate in the hands of the gods.

18. Sharpay and Ryan from High School Musical

The seemingly villainous duo of Sharpay and Ryan in High School Musical takes on a different shade when you consider their perspective. Troy and Gabriella, while the protagonists, often exhibit a lack of respect for others' time and efforts. Sharpay and Ryan, on the other hand, are hardworking individuals who know what they want and have been working towards their goals since childhood.

Having worked hard for years to secure the lead roles in the school musical, their disappointment when the roles are given to others is relatable. From their viewpoint, it is a matter of fairness and recognition for their efforts.

19. Pagan Min from Far Cry 4

In the video game Far Cry 4, the perception of Pagan Min as the antagonist undergoes a profound shift when viewed from a different angle. While undeniably an awful person, Pagan Min emerges as the best of a bad situation in the chaotic world of Kyrat. The leaders of the Golden Path, whom you are forced to choose between, reveal their dark sides, involving the forced servitude and execution of innocent civilians.

Pagan Min, in contrast, remains honest with the player, Ajay, throughout the game. Following his instructions yields a surprisingly short and peaceful resolution, avoiding the civil war altogether. Pagan, ruthless as he may be, arguably has Ajay's best interests at heart, making players question the conventional definitions of good and bad in a morally complex world.

20. Magneto in X-Men

Magneto comics poster.
Image source

Magneto, the iconic X-Men character, often finds himself cast as the villain, but his perspective brings a compelling layer of sympathy. His belief that humans would try to destroy mutants is proven right, as evidenced by the persecution and discrimination mutants face. Magneto's extreme methods may be questionable, but they stem from a lifetime of witnessing the harsh reality of human hostility toward mutants.

His character challenges the simplistic dichotomy of good and evil, forcing us to grapple with the complex motivations and experiences that shape individuals in the X-Men universe. It becomes hard not to feel empathy for Magneto, considering the adversity he faced in both life and humanity.

21. Mr. Wilson in Dennis the Menace

In the movie Dennis the Menace, the character of Mr. Wilson becomes an unexpected figure deserving of sympathy when viewed through a different lens. Dennis's mischievous antics may be amusing, but the frustration experienced by Mr. Wilson in dealing with the aftermath of the chaos becomes palpable.

The portrayal of Mr. Wilson as a victim of Dennis's mischief prompts a reconsideration of the typical hero-villain dynamic in family comedies, where the mischievous child is often celebrated at the expense of the adults.

22. Shere Khan in The Jungle Book

Shere Khan, the formidable tiger in The Jungle Book, takes on a different perspective when you consider his motivations. His primary desire is to eat and maintain the natural order of the jungle by keeping humans out. Shere Khan's actions, driven by instinct and a desire to protect his territory, challenge the conventional portrayal of him as a mere antagonist.

While his methods may be ruthless, his goal of preserving the jungle's balance becomes more relatable. The story prompts us to consider whether Shere Khan is actually a bad guy or just a creature attempting to survive in a world with human interference.

23. Walter Peck in Ghostbusters

Walter Peck, the EPA representative in Ghostbusters, is often seen as an obstructionist bureaucrat, but his perspective sheds light on legitimate concerns. The Ghostbusters' proton packs, unlicensed nuclear accelerators, were built without regulations or inspections. From Peck's point of view, it is perfectly reasonable and legal for the EPA to investigate the storage facility and the equipment.

This nuanced portrayal challenges the audience to consider the consequences of unbridled scientific innovation and prompts a reevaluation of who the real "bad guy" is in a story that blurs the lines between supernatural threats and human accountability.

24. The Ancient Ones: Cabin in the Woods

The Cabin in the Woods is a unique horror film that plays with genre conventions and blurs the lines between good and evil. While at first glance, the "Ancient Ones" who orchestrate the ritual sacrifices within the cabin might seem like straightforward villains, a closer look reveals a more nuanced situation.

The Ancient Ones, monstrous entities representing humanity's primal fears, are kept at bay by the annual ritual sacrifice of five "expendable" college students. While gruesome, this sacrifice ensures global harmony and prevents the apocalypse. From their perspective, they are simply playing a necessary role in a cosmic game of survival.

25. Megatron in Transformers

Megatron statue.

Megatron, the leader of the Decepticons in Transformers, takes on a more sympathetic light when you explore the origins of the conflict on Cybertron. Born into the lowest caste, Megatron and his fellow Decepticons had limited options for survival. Forced into gladiator pits where survival meant killing or being killed, their rebellion against a corrupt political system is actually understandable.

Megatron's actions, while extreme, are born out of a desire to overthrow a broken caste system and bring about change for the oppressed. The narrative challenges us to question whether Megatron's rebellion is a fight for justice against a corrupt system.

26. King Triton in The Little Mermaid

In The Little Mermaid, King Triton's protective stance towards his teenage daughter Ariel is often seen as overbearing. However, when viewed through the lens of a concerned parent, his apprehension about Ariel shacking up with an adult man is justified.

Triton's fear for Ariel's safety and well-being in a world where she might not fully understand the consequences of her actions makes him a relatable and caring father. Similarly, Ursula's intervention, while portrayed as villainous, serves as a cautionary lesson about the dangers of making impulsive decisions for love.

27. Clover in Cloverfield

In Cloverfield, the giant monster Clover takes on a more sympathetic tone when considering its circumstances. A baby giant monster, confused and trapped in a city, becomes the target of relentless attacks from military forces. Awoken abruptly, Clover is thrust into a hostile environment where it faces machine guns, tanks, rockets, and even carpet bombing.

The audience is forced to empathize with the creature's plight as it becomes a victim of circumstance. It is a conventional monster movie dynamic that highlights the vulnerability of being thrust into a world that reacts with fear and aggression rather than understanding.

28. The Falmer in Skyrim

In the vast and immersive world of Skyrim, the Falmer emerges as a tragic tale of victims turned villains. Once proud Snow Elves, they were driven underground by the Nords, who invaded their homeland. Seeking refuge, they attempted to form an alliance with the dwarves, only to be betrayed and transformed into the violent creatures known as the Falmer.

To add insult to injury, adventurers often invade their caves, using shouts and fire to steal their possessions and mercilessly kill them. The Falmer, a once-noble race, has become a poignant reminder of the consequences of betrayal and the cyclical nature of victimhood.

29. Hades in Mythology

Hades, often portrayed as the ominous ruler of the Underworld, takes on a different role when viewed from a different perspective. Rather than being an inherently malevolent figure, Hades finds himself in the Underworld due to circumstances beyond his control. His role is to maintain order and deliver justice to souls, a duty that comes with the territory of being the god of the Underworld.

In comparison, other gods, particularly Zeus, often exhibit more ruthless and capricious behavior. Hades is a symbol of a divine being doing a necessary job with a sense of duty, challenging the simplistic portrayal of him as the ultimate villain in Greek mythology.

30. Ross in the Cat Episode of Friends

Cast of FRIENDS.

In the Friends episode, where Phoebe believes her dead mother is reincarnated as a cat, Ross is presented as the voice of reason. While Phoebe's belief is portrayed humorously, Ross's skepticism is justified in the context of the show's reality.

In this instance, Ross's role as the "bad guy" prompts viewers to question the absurdity of certain situations and whether skepticism should be dismissed outright.

31. David from Shaun of the Dead

While not a traditional villain, David from Shaun of the Dead does play a contrasting role in Shaun's plan. David's skepticism about Shaun's plan is justified when the plan inevitably goes awry, leading to tragic consequences for David, Diane, and Ed. His foresight and caution serve as a reminder that sometimes well-intentioned plans can have unintended and dire outcomes.

In a world where survival is paramount, David's realistic outlook adds a layer of complexity to the narrative, challenging the typical hero's journey and highlighting the harsh realities of a zombie apocalypse.

32. The Wicked Witch of the West in The Wizard of Oz

The Wicked Witch of the West is often seen as the quintessential villain in The Wizard of Oz, but a closer look at her character reveals a different perspective. Her actions, driven by the desire to reclaim her sister's ruby slippers and the fear of the powerful Oz, can be interpreted as a response to perceived threats.

From her standpoint, Dorothy's accidental arrival and the subsequent actions of the inhabitants of Oz are intrusions and threats to her realm. This story challenges us to consider the Witch's point of view and question whether her actions are justified reactions to perceived threats rather than pure villainy.

33. Erik Killmonger in Black Panther

Erik Killmonger, the antagonist in Black Panther, desires to use Wakanda's advanced technology to empower oppressed communities worldwide, which is clearly rooted in a genuine concern for social justice. Killmonger's anger and radical methods stem from a history of systemic injustice and oppression.

The film prompts us to question whether Killmonger's motivations, though extreme, hold a valid point about the responsibility of a powerful nation to address global inequality. His character adds a layer of complexity to the traditional hero-villain dichotomy, urging the audience to consider the broader implications of Wakanda's isolationist policies.

34. Sid from Toy Story

Sid, the seemingly destructive neighbor in Toy Story, takes on a different perspective when you consider his lack of knowledge about the secret lives of toys. Unaware that toys are alive and feel things, Sid's creative destruction is a result of his innocent curiosity. The toys never communicated their sentience to him, and when he did become aware, he was horrified.

Sid's destructive play surgeries, though unconventional, could be seen as a form of a kid’s creative expression rather than malicious intent.

35. The Hyenas in The Lion King

Hyenas from Lion King.
Image source

The hyenas in The Lion King, particularly Shenzi, Banzai, and Ed, are often relegated to the role of secondary antagonists. However, their exile to the elephant graveyard raises questions about the lions' prejudices against them.

Mufasa's decision to banish the hyenas seems arbitrary, and when they sing about taking over, their primary focus is on securing food. The hyenas' plight sheds light on social dynamics and discrimination, challenging the notion of them being purely villainous.

36. William "D-Fens" Foster in Falling Down

In the film Falling Down, William Foster, also known as "D-Fens," is often portrayed as the antagonist as he goes on a violent and destructive rampage across Los Angeles. However, his character challenges the audience to question the societal pressures and frustrations that lead an ordinary man to such extremes.

Foster's actions, although extreme, highlight the toll of systemic issues like unemployment, societal expectations, and personal failures. The narrative prompts viewers to consider whether, in some aspects, Foster's grievances are a reflection of deeper societal problems rather than the actions of a purely villainous character.

37. The Bugs in Starship Troopers

In Starship Troopers, the portrayal of humanity as space fascists and the bugs as counter-attacking victims adds a layer of complexity to the conventional hero-villain dynamic. The bugs, often seen as mindless enemies, are revealed to be defending their territory against human colonization attempts in their space.

The story makes us question the ethics of human expansion and the consequences of viewing an alien species as an enemy to be conquered.

38. Skyler White in Breaking Bad

Skyler White, a character in Breaking Bad, undergoes a complex transformation in the eyes of the audience upon closer examination. Initially disliked by some viewers, Skyler's reactions and decisions become more understandable upon a second watch. Skyler finds herself in an unimaginable situation with a newborn and a husband, Walter White, spiraling into a dangerous criminal world.

Upon reflection, Skyler's resistance to Walt's criminal activities and her sacrifices for the sake of her family is justifiable. Skyler's actions can be seen as a form of self-preservation in a situation where she feels held hostage by Walt's descent into criminality.

39. Maximus in Inhumans

Maximus, portrayed as the antagonist in Inhumans, is revealed to be fighting for a just cause—freeing slaves. The show's narrative challenges us to question their allegiance to Black Bolt and the royal family, urging them to empathize with Maximus's struggle for equality and justice.

The complexity of the characters in Inhumans blurs the lines between hero and villain, prompting a reevaluation of traditional story dynamics.

40. Thanos in Avengers: Infinity War

Thanos statue.

While Thanos is undoubtedly portrayed as the ultimate villain in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, his motivation introduces a complex moral dilemma. Thanos seeks to eliminate half of all life in the universe to address overpopulation and resource depletion, believing it will restore balance.

His conviction, while extreme, stems from a warped sense of responsibility to prevent widespread suffering. This challenges us to grapple with the ethical dimensions of Thanos' plan, questioning whether the perceived villain may have a point in addressing existential threats to the universe.

41. The Shark in Jaws

In Jaws, the shark, often depicted as the relentless predator, is actually a victim of circumstances. The ocean is its natural habitat, where its species have thrived for millions of years.

The shark is merely following its instincts, and the resulting deaths are a consequence of human negligence. Jaws challenges the perception of the shark as a villain and prompts viewers to consider the impact of human decisions on wildlife, questioning who the real antagonist is in this tale of survival.

42. Mr. Belding from Saved by the Bell

Mr. Belding, the principal in Saved by the Bell, takes on a different perspective when considering the actions of Zack Morris and his friends. Zack, portrayed as the charming protagonist, often engages in manipulative and sociopathic behavior. Mr. Belding's attempts to discipline or guide Zack reflect a desire to maintain order and provide a safe, educational environment.

Zack's friends, in their enabling behavior, contribute to the challenges Mr. Belding faces. From Mr. Belding's viewpoint, dealing with a student like Zack is a daily struggle, making him a more sympathetic figure in the narrative.

43. Todd and Margo in National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation

In National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation, Todd and Margo, the neighbors, are often portrayed as uptight and inconsiderate. Their reactions, however, are more understandable when one considers the mayhem that Clark Griswold's antics caused. Living next to someone who causes literal property damage and creates chaos can be frustrating.

The Griswold family's constant disruption may be the cause of Todd and Margo's tense demeanor.

43 Stories Where the Bad Guy Was Right pinterest image.

More Interesting